Home Virginia Politics UVA Files Suit Against Ken Kook-inelli

UVA Files Suit Against Ken Kook-inelli

511
11
SHARE

Go UVA!

“Academic freedom is essential to the mission of our Nation’s institutions of higher learning and a core First Amendment concern. As Thomas Jefferson intended, the University of Virginia has a long and proud tradition of embracing the ‘illimitable freedom of the human mind’ by fully endorsing and supporting faculty research and scholarly pursuits. Our Nation also has a long and proud tradition of limited government framed by enumerated powers which Jefferson ardently believed was necessary for a civil society to endure.”

This is the preliminary statement of a petition filed today by the University of Virginia to “set aside” the Civil Investigative Demands (CIDs) issued to the University by Attorney General Kenneth T. Cuccinelli II on April 23, 2010.

In announcing today’s filing, University President John T. Casteen III said the University intends to protect academic freedom. Casteen said that issuance of the CIDs “has sent a chill through the Commonwealth’s colleges and universities – a chill that has reached across the country and attracted the attention of all of higher education.”

The CIDs seek to investigate the research activities of Michael Mann, an assistant professor of environmental sciences at the University from 1999 to 2005. Mann, who has since joined the faculty of The Pennsylvania State University, is known for his research on global warming.

On May 14, Casteen announced that the Board of Visitors had engaged the law firm of Hogan Lovells and its premier education practice group to represent and advise the University in its response to the CIDs.  

Rector John O. Wynne said that the University is prepared to fight for the right of its research faculty to engage in debate and free expression without fear of reprisal. “We are fighting for preservation of the basic principles on which our country was founded,” he said.

The University’s petition, which was filed in Albemarle County Circuit Court this afternoon, is the first step in a legal process to set aside the CIDs. In addition to challenging the CIDs on academic freedom grounds, the petition also argues that the attorney general exceeded his authority under the state’s Fraud Against Taxpayers Act.

A CID has the legal force of a subpoena. The CIDs issued to the University are extremely broad and far-reaching, requesting information and documents in connection with five grants as well as correspondence between Mann and more than 40 scientists and other individuals over an 11-year period.

The five grants at issue – four of them awarded by federal agencies and involving the disbursement of federal funds – totaled some $466,000.

Earlier this month, the University’s Faculty Senate issued a statement regarding the CIDs, reflecting the organization’s concern that this investigation would have a “chilling effect” on scientific inquiry worldwide.

Ann Hamric, chair of the Faculty Senate and a professor in the School of Nursing, said she was deeply grateful to University leaders for mounting a vigorous defense of academic freedom.  

“I join with my faculty colleagues in applauding this action from our president and Board of Visitors,” she said. “Academic freedom is crucial to the academic life of our (and any) university.”

  • n/t

  • Bumble Bee

    and shame on the people of Virginia for electing that barfbag as attorney general

  • leedynamo

    A bully only understands one thing.

  • leedynamo

    I’ll assign the shame to the political parties, one for nominating him and one for not committing to strong, statewide organization that can elect down ballot candidates regardless of the candidate for Governor.

  • kindler

    For protecting freedom of thought from government bullying…

    For supporting the US as a place that respects and supports open scientific inquiry…

    For following the vision and mandate of your founder, the Sage of Monticello, who can rest a little easier tonight.

    And best of luck in court. This should be an open and shut case, but let’s not hesitate to take it to the Supremes if necessary…

  • TomPaine

    for standing up to the “bully of Virginia”!

  • Elaine in Roanoke

    Thomas Jefferson would be proud of “his” university. Let’s stand up to bigoted and misinformed bullies. It’s our freedom that’s a stake.

  • libra

    My money is on UVA.

  • Old Redneck

    “Academic freedom is essential to the mission of our Nation’s institutions of higher learning and a core First Amendment concern.”

    TRANSLATION:  ” Mr. Attorney General:  Shove your CID’s up your ass. “

  • Old Redneck

    Here’s a PDF of the UVA response.

    http://www.virginia.edu/uvatod

    It’s a thing of beauty.

    How about someone posting the email address for the UVA president so we can send him messages of support??

  • TomPaine

    is attempting to conduct a fishing expedition into a pond from which fishing is barred by law.  

    Cooch is going to have his litigation butt handed to him in a mighty embarassing and uncomfortable basket.