Faith=No Muslims. Charity=No Government Spending. Hope=No Obama.

    311
    3
    SHARE

    ( – promoted by lowkell)

    cross-posted from Sum of Change and check out Pam Spaulding’s post at PHB for more thoughts and discussion.

    Yesterday we sent cameras to Glenn Beck’s 828 rally and Al Sharpton’s rally and march. We posted a handfull of videos from each. But first, a personal comment, if you don’t mind. My parents and grandparents were civil rights activists (not to mention anti-war activists and labor organizers). On the same grass where we stood yesterday, my mother stood 47 years ago to watch Martin Luther King Jr. declare his dream for the world. I highly doubt anyone will remember yesterday the way my mother remembers 47 years ago.

    We will begin with Beck’s event::



    Sumofchange – Marcy and John from Ohio – Interview at Beck’s 828 Rally

    As everyone knows by now, the crowd at Beck’s event was pretty big. As bernardpliers points out, it was no 500,000, but it was still pretty big. I talked to a bunch of folks, had some good, and some not-so-good, conversations. I am not going to ty to sum up everything I heard other than to say this: for a non-political event, we heard little but talk of politics. And the reason we heard little but politics is because the statement “restoring honor,” is being used as a political statement. Faith=No Muslims. Charity=No Government Spending. Hope=No Obama.



    Sumofchange – Dave from Florida – Interview at Beck’s 828 Rally



    Sumofchange – Debate in the Crowd at Beck’s 828 Rally



    Sumofchange – Sights of the Crowd at Beck’s 828 Rally

    Another observation about Beck’s rally, I have never, ever, ever, heard so many people worried that we are going to take their words out of context. We assured folks we would not, but it became such an issue that for the first time we told folks, “Anyone in our videos, if you feel we took your words out of context, you can send me an email and we will run a explanation from you, unedited. I can’t guarantee we won’t respond, but we will run the quote.” Frankly, I think they are completely justified to have that concern (See: Sherrod), I have just never witnessed it on such extreme levels. That being said, we posted raw footage. No one can claim we took their words out of context. I believe I gave everyone I talked to a fair opportunity to make their voice heard.

    Last observation, for a group of people who were, supposedly, reclaiming the civil rights movement, they sure did a good job avoiding the subject. Not one person we spoke with brought it up.

    Meanwhile, in another part of town…



    Sumofchange – Rev Frederick Haynes – Pastor of Friendship-West Baptist Church



    Sumofchange – Rita Lassiter – President of The Thursday Network at Sharpton’s

    A little reminder of how the original teabaggers got away with it…



    Sumofchange – Original Tea Partiers Turned on Native Americans



    Sumofchange – Melanie Campbell – Exec Dir and CEO National Coalition on Black Civic Participation



    Sumofchange – Benjamin Jealous – President and CEO of th NAACP on 8/28

    Last, but certainly not least, a message about REAL taxation without representation:



    Sumofchange – Ilir Zherka – Exec Dir of DC Vote at 8/28

    • Dan Sullivan

      The themes in contrast:

      At the Mall:

      I came out to try and restore honor…

      Bridges to nowhere, tunnels for turtles…

      Several generations fed and clothed from birth to death…

      Cut all programs except national defense…

      The Muslim religion is about hatred and killing infidels which is Christians…

      and outside of the Mall:

      If God is for us, who can be against us?

      Today is not the day to kill or sabotage the progress that we have made…

      Redeem the dream; reclaim the dream…

      I looked up…granddad you were right…it was a cold day…

      Number one on their list: don’t bring your sign; number two on their list: don’t bring your gun…

      and I look forward to the damning videos of members of the counter-march.