The myth of private, for-profit, healthcare insurance

    317
    5
    SHARE

    The great myth is that private, for-profit, healthcare insurance will somehow lead to greater efficiencies and better service in the healthcare field. The same individuals who argue these points are also the ones who usually posit the self-interested nature of individuals. However, if forgoing profit for the sake of bettering someone’s health is not in a company’s best interest, why does it follow that the said company will offer the suffering person appropriate healthcare insurance coverage?

    It doesn’t of course, and we are left with one side of the healthcare insurance debate arguing behind an ideological brick-wall while the other side argues from logic and facts (No, Fox News does not count). Even some of the most ideologically opposed to public healthcare insurance will admit that Medicare has been a successful government-run program. But, they’ll argue, it could be more efficiently run if it were privatized.

    One need only listen to a handful of the outrageous stories regarding private health insurance companies denying needy individuals appropriate healthcare coverage in some of their most trying times to understand just how “efficient” private healthcare insurance can be.

    What, really, is the difference, anyways, between a highly centralized public form of healthcare insurance and a highly centralized form of private healthcare insurance? The biggest difference is that the former is not concerned with turning a profit and can, therefore, cover the expensive healthcare costs of sick individuals without fear of market backlash or shareholder angst.  

    Not everything in this world can or should be privatized because not everything in this world is more efficient or effective when privatized. Healthcare insurance is one of those exemptions.  

    • glennbear

      To overly simplify things………$100 in premiums sent to a private insurance company has to support return to stockholders, pay claims, and enrich company executives.

      $100 of Medicare dollars has to pay claims PERIOD !!!

        On a local level we have seen how great the privatization of VA IT services has worked out for taxpayers.