Home GLBT Supreme Court “Stay” Order in “Bostic” Marriage Equality Case

Supreme Court “Stay” Order in “Bostic” Marriage Equality Case


Unfortunately, there will be no LGBT marriages tomorrow in Virginia. Hopefully, that situation will change very soon.

  • Dan Sullivan

    This will be very interesting for the conservatives on the court. They must be scouring for any contemporary reference to marriage that might be relevant. This wasn’t a topic of conversation in the 18th century or at the Constitutional Convention, so they are going to have to focus on broad principles of freedom rather than look for a narrow rationalization for personal prejudice.

  • Here is a statement from James Parrish, EV’s Executive Director:

    “It is disappointing that the Supreme Court stayed the 4th Circuit Court’s decision. Lesbian and gay Virginians have waited long enough for the freedom to marry. Loving couples – and families – should not have to endure yet another standstill before their commitment to one another is recognized here in Virginia. Every day that this ruling is stayed, more lesbian and gay Virginians will suffer undue harm as they wait to insure their spouses, wait to adopt the children they are raising, and wait to have their relationships affirmed by the Commonwealth. Equality Virginia urges the Supreme Court to take this case as soon as possible and hopes that it will rule once and for all in favor of marriage equality.”

  • Today, the Supreme Court of the United States granted a motion by the Prince William County Clerk of Court to stay the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals’ decision striking down Virginia’s ban on marriage for same-sex couples. This means that no marriages between same-sex couples may be performed or recognized until the Supreme Court has an opportunity to evaluate requests for review of the case. Attorney General Mark Herring, a supporter of marriage equality who successfully argued against Virginia’s marriage ban at the federal district and appeals levels, has already petitioned the Supreme Court for prompt review of the case, and has taken steps to allow the Court to resolve the constitutional issues quickly and definitively.

    Attorney General Herring issued the following statement regarding the Supreme Court’s stay:

    “This case has moved with extraordinary pace, from filing to a possible review by the U.S. Supreme Court in just one year. But it is still difficult to expect Virginians to wait to exercise what I believe is a fundamental right, especially when we are so close to our goal. That’s why I’ve been fighting for marriage equality and working to expedite the case so the Supreme Court can definitively answer the constitutional questions about marriage equality and permanently protect the families of Virginia’s same-sex couples. I reluctantly agreed that a stay was warranted in light of the way the Supreme Court handled a nearly identical case in Utah, and because of the potential that an adverse Supreme Court ruling might cause children adopted by a second parent to have that adoption heartbreakingly invalidated, death benefits conferred to grieving spouses taken away, and spousal benefits families thought would pay the bills thrown into limbo.

    “Virginia’s case is waiting for the Supreme Court’s review, as are several others from around the country, and I have petitioned for an extraordinarily speedy review from the Court. Virginia families suffer each day that this decision is delayed.”