Home Virginia Politics Federal complaint filed after anti-immigrant sentiment kills housing deal in Lawrenceville, VA

Federal complaint filed after anti-immigrant sentiment kills housing deal in Lawrenceville, VA

191
3
SHARE

Cross posted from Story of America: A Nation Divided

A federal complaint has been filed by Housing Opportunities Made Equal (HOME) citing events that I witnessed and documented for Story of America. On June 20, 2014, I traveled to Lawrenceville, Virginia to film an emergency town hall meeting about the possibility of putting an Unaccompanied Alien Children’s (UAC) program on the campus of the recently closed St. Paul’s College.

HOME’s complaint argues that immigrant minors were denied equal housing opportunity and subjected to discriminatory statements when public outcry, much of it clearly hateful, was cited as the primary reason for moving the program elsewhere. I have shared portions of the many hours of video I shot with HOME upon their request.

I learned a lot from reading HOME’s press release below. In fact, it changed my outlook on what I saw that frightful evening. The lesson for me is this: sometimes public sentiment appears to be so passionate and so overwhelming that we assume it to be the only meaningful consideration when making public policy. But what happens if that sentiment, and the decisions that stem from that sentiment, violate constitutional rights and other rights that are protected by law? Although I did not see it on June 20th, I see now that the events I witnessed in Lawrenceville may be such a case.

It’s easy to forget that our nation decided to outlaw unequal treatment based on race 150 years ago, and again 50 years ago. Whether or not political entertainment combine with current events to popularize overt discrimination, the law is the law, and it needs to be enforced.

The bottom-line is that our Constitution and legal system protects minority rights despite popular opinion. It’s easy to forget this when the popular opinion is expressed so loudly and dramatically.

Below is the Story of America video I released in June documenting some of the discriminatory statements that are mentioned in the federal complaint.

CLICK HERE to read the blog post I wrote at the time, and please read HOME’s press release below:  

For Immediate Release September 25, 2014  

Federal Fair Housing Complaint Filed Against The Town of Lawrenceville,
Brunswick County, and Sheriff Roberts

Every person in the U.S. is protected by the Fair Housing Act
regardless of their immigration status.

Housing Opportunities Made Equal of Virginia, Inc. (HOME) and St. Paul’s College announce the filing of a federal housing discrimination complaint at the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) against the Town of Lawrenceville, Brunswick County, and Brunswick County Sheriff Brian Roberts. The complaint alleges that participants of the Unaccompanied Alien Children’s (UAC) program were denied an equal housing opportunity and subjected to discriminatory statements based on their national origin, race, and/or color. In addition, a civil rights discrimination complaint has been filed against the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) in their Office of Civil Rights for failing to honor its contract with St. Paul’s, making housing unavailable to UAC children based on their national origin, race, and/or color.

In June 2014, Saint Paul’s College, a private enterprise zoned for such use, negotiated a contract with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services to provide shelter for up to 500 immigrant children without parents in the United States. Upon being informed of the impending lease contract and after meaningful consultation with the college, elected and employed officials of the town of Lawrenceville and Brunswick County orchestrated and implemented a plan to block the deal. Purported concerns by these individuals are grounded in false stereotypes about Latinos and reflect discrimination based on race, color, and/or national origin.

Among other actions, Brunswick County Sheriff Brian Roberts also made discriminatory statements to the media about UAC participants. “There is this negative perception of gang violence – these people are coming from Central America,” he said, squarely attributing the discrimination to stereotypes based on the children’s national origin. Once the contract was fully executed by HHS and St. Paul’s, the same group of municipal officials continued their push to rescind it. Their efforts were successful, and HHS pulled out of the contract on June 20, 2014.

Dr. Millard (Pete) Stith, President of St. Paul’s College, stated, “Despite the blessing of Lawrenceville officials and Lawrenceville’s assurance that proper zoning requirements were met for the Unaccompanied Alien Children’s (UAC) program, the United States Department of Health and Human Services removed St. Paul’s College as a host location despite a fully executed contract. Because of this decision, St. Paul’s College has been severely injured. The school would have received $160,000 a month in rent from the federal government. This project would have given St. Paul’s College the much-needed funding to complete necessary improvements to the campus and repay creditors.” Failure to implement the contract has made housing unavailable to UAC participants based on their national origin, race, and/or color.

Heather Mullins Crislip, President & CEO of Housing Opportunities Made Equal of Virginia, Inc., added that “The Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination by housing providers, including municipalities, whose discriminatory practices make housing unavailable to persons on account of race or color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status, or disability. Every person in the United States is protected by the Fair Housing Act regardless of their immigration status. Our investigation revealed that the federal Fair Housing Act was violated when the St. Paul’s contract was rescinded because of discriminatory push-back from the town.”

HOME encourages officials to reconsider their opposition for this arrangement and propose a solution that does not violate federal fair housing laws. Not only was this action a violation of federal fair housing law, it also denied the community a much needed boost to its economic activity and a path out of the crushing debt facing the College. HOME welcomes further discussion on the matter as it relates to fair housing rights and obligations.

Important Points:

  • The Fair Housing Act (FHA), 42 U.S.C. 3601 et seq., prohibits discrimination by housing providers, including municipalities, whose discriminatory practices make housing unavailable to persons on account of race or color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status, or disability.

  • Precedent has been set: the U.S. Department of Justice has taken enforcement action against local municipalities that have attempted to reduce or limit the number of Hispanic families that live in their communities.  http://www.justice.gov/crt/about/hce/housing_coverage.php#nat
  • Title VI, 42 U.S.C. § 2000d et seq., was enacted as part of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. It prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, and national origin in programs and activities receiving federal financial assistance which includes local municipalities.
  • St. Paul’s College was assured by Lawrenceville’s town manager that proper zoning requirements were met for this program because it satisfied allowable uses for its current zoning designation. In addition, the college also reached out to the Lawrenceville police chief and fire chief prior to the execution of the contract. These three individuals gave St. Paul’s their blessing to move forward with the plan.

_________________________________________________________________________________________

Housing Opportunities Made Equal of Virginia, Inc. (HOME), founded in 1971, is a statewide fair housing non-profit. HOME’s mission is to ensure equal access to housing for all people. HOME investigates housing discrimination and provides support for discrimination victims. You can learn more about HOME and all of its services at www.HOMEofVA.org  

St. Paul’s College (SPC) was founded in 1888 as a private historically black college.  In 2013, the college closed because it lost its accreditation from the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools. In the years leading up to its closure, SPC accrued approximately $4 million in debt.  SPC pursued several options to try to satisfy its debt, including partnerships with other schools or the commonwealth of Virginia, but those attempts were unsuccessful, and the school closed on June 28, 2013.

__________________________________________________________________________________________

Educational Takeaways:

The Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination in the sale, rental, and financing of housing, and in other housing-related transactions based on race, color, national origin, religion, gender, disability, familial status, and being at least 55 years old.

National Origin means where you are from or perceived to be from, and includes ancestry, ethnicity, birthplace, culture, and language. Sometimes national origin discrimination is based on perceptions or stereotypes related to the language someone speaks or their citizenship status.

Examples of potential national origin discrimination include:

    • Making housing unavailable based on stereotypes of your national origin.
    • Refusing to rent to people who don’t speak English.
    • Charging a higher rent or security deposit based on ethnicity.
    • Making offensive statements about where you are from or calling you names because of where you are from.
    • Housing advertisements stating that persons are preferred or not wanted because of their ethnicity.
    • Steering or restricting persons to one area of a building or complex because of where they are from.
    • Requiring only people from different countries show extra forms of identification to apply for housing.
    • Refusing to allow you to communicate with an interpreter or refusing to rent to you because you need an interpreter.
    • Not allowing you to use amenities within the complex or restricting your use of the amenities because of your ancestry.

Contact:

Mike Burnette, Housing Opportunities Made Equal of Virginia, Inc. (HOME)

(804) 354-0641 x118, mburnette@HOMEofVA.org  

Dr. Millard “Pete” Stith, President, St. Paul’s College
(434) 848-6401 mdstith@saintpauls.edu

  • Dan Sullivan

    There was nothing civil in this discourse.