Highlights and Lowlights from the 2015 Virginia Sierra Club General Assembly Scorecard


    The Virginia Sierra Club scorecard for 2015 is now available, and sadly, an issue that should equally concern all of us – protecting the environment we all inhabit – continues to show a lamentable, absurd, frustrating partisan divide. For instance, courtesy of Ivy Main’s Power for the People VA blog, note that every single Senator and Delegate receiving a perfect Sierra Club environmental score is a…yep, Democrat.

    Thirteen Senators scored a perfect 100%, including Sen. Barker (D-39), Sen. Colgan (D-29), Sen. Dance (D-16), Sen. Ebbin (D-30), Sen. Favola (D-31), Sen. Howell (D-32), Sen. Lewis (D-6), Sen. Lucas (D-18), Sen. Marsden (D-37), Sen. McEachin (D-9), Sen. Miller (D-1), Sen. Petersen (D-34) and Sen. Wexton (D-33).

    Twenty-five Delegates scored a perfect 100%, including Del. Bulova (D-37), Del. Carr (D-69), Del. Filler-Corn (D-41), Del. Futrell (D-2), Del. Herring (D-46), Del. Hester (D-89), Del. Hope (D-47), Del. Keam (D-35), Del. Krupicka (D-45), Del. Lopez (D-49), Del. Mason (D-93), Del. McClellan (D-71), Del. McQuinn (D-70), Del. Morrissey (I-74), Del. Murphy (D-34), Del. Plum (D-36), Del. Preston (D-63), Del. Sickles (D-43), Del. Simon (D-53), Del. Spruill (D-77), Del. Sullivan (D-48), Del. Surovell (D-44), Del. Toscano (D-57), Del. Ward (D-92) and Del. Watts (D-39).

    Again, I take no real pleasure in that list (although THANK YOU to everyone who voted for the environment, not for the polluters, in 2015!). The fact is, Republicans and Democrats breath the air and drink the water equally, so there really should be no partisan divide at all when it comes to the environment. Also, even if you’re utterly cynical about it, the fact is that BOTH parties receive a lot of money from Dominion Power and other fossil fuel interests (although no doubt Republicans receive even more dirty fuel dollars than Democrats do), so again that should cut against such a stark partisan divide as we see in Virginia. Yet here we are, even as the science is screaming at us about the enormous environmental challenges we ALL face, with this stark partisan divide on what SHOULD be an utterly non-partisan issue.

    In that context, you’ll understand why I find it sad and outrageous to see the Republican Party — formerly the party of conservationist Teddy Roosevelt and even Richard Nixon, who did some excellent things for the environment — become an earth-pillaging, Koch-sucking disaster. With that, here are the worst of the worst in the Virginia General Assembly, the Republicans who received “D” or “F” grades from the Sierra Club.

    Senators Black, Carrico, Chafin, Cosgrove, Garrett, Hanger, Martin, McDougle, McWaters, Newman, Obenshain, Reeves, Ruff, Smith, Stanley, Stuart, Wagner.

    Delegates Adams, Albo, Anderson, Austin, Bell D., Bell R., Berg, Bloxom, Byron, Campbell, Cline, Cole, Cox, Davis, DeSteph, Edmunds, Faris, Farrell, Fowler, Garrett, Gilbert, Greason, Habeeb, Head, Helsel, Hodges, Howell, Hugo, Ingram, Jones, Kilgore, Knight, Landes, LaRock, Leftwich, LeMunyon, Lingamfelter, Loupassi, Marshall D., Marshall R., Massie, Miller, Minchew, Morefeld, Morris, O’Bannon, O’Quinn, Orrock, Peace, Pillion, Pogge, Poindexter, Ramadan, Ransone, Robinson, Rush, Rust, Scott, Stolle, Taylor, Villanueva, Ware, Webert, Wilt, Wright, Yancey, Yost.

    Oh yeah, and let’s not forget two “Democrats”: the godawful Johnny Joannou (“F” grade) and also Matthew James (“D” grade). No excuses there, but at least in Joannou’s case, he has an opponent (Steve Heretick), who hopefully will beat him on June 9! As for the rest of the “D” and “F” Senators and Delegates, polling clearly shows that they are wildly out of step with their constituents, large percentages of whom (of both parties) support   switching to clean energy and reducing carbon pollution.  The question is, why aren’t their supposed “representatives” listening to their constituents?!?

    • See here. This is a far-right-wing group so keep in mind that the LOWER the score (on a scale of 0-100) the better. Also keep in mind that what this group is mostly about is imposing their fundamentalist religious beliefs – no abortion in any case (including rape or incest); no LGBT equality or protections against discrimination; defunding Planned Parenthood; etc. With that in mind…

      The best Senators were all Democrats: Creigh Deeds (5 points); Rosalyn Dance (8 points); Toddy Puller (10); Jennifer Wexton (11); John Miller (11); Donald McEachin (11); Mamie Locke (11); Janet Howell (11); Barbara Favola (11); John Edwards (11); Adam Ebbin (11); George Barker (11); Dick Saslaw (12); Dave Marsden (12); Kenny Alexander (17); Louise Lucas (18); Lynwood Lewis (25); Chap Petersen (26); Chuck Colgan (33).

      The WORST Senators — all Republicans: Ryan McDougle (100); Jeff McWaters (100); Steve Newman (100); Mark Obenshain (100); Ralph Smith (100); Bill Stanley (100); Richard Stuart (100); Tom Garrett (95); Steve Martin (95); Bryce Reeves (95); Bill Carrico (94); John Cosgrove (94); Tommy Norment (94); Frank Ruff (94); Frank Wagner (94); Ben Chafin (93); Dick Black (89); Emmett Hanger (89); Jill Holtzman Vogel (76); Walter Stosch (76).

      On the House side there were a few that jumped out at me.

      “Democrat” Johnny Joannou received an 83 score. Gack.

      Mr. Morality (not!) Joe Morrissey (formerly “D”) received a pretty high 44 score.

      Democrats Joe Preston and Lionell Spruill received 40 and 33 scores respectively – definitely too high from the “Familiy Foundation.”

      The most “moderate” Republican on the list (Tom Rust) still received a decent 44 score from this extreme group. The vast majority of Republicans were in the 80-100 range. Bunch of nuts.