Tuesday’s debate had this unusual twist in the ideological jostling between Tom Perriello and Ralph Northam: the revelation that Tom Perriello is secretly a Libertarian Party mole!
Or at least that’s how Ralph Northam is pitching this. Footage of the exchange below:
The Northam campaign backed up their claim with an old 2009 article in which the reporter notes that Perriello was “a libertarian at heart.”
The Perriello campaign has responded that one of Tom’s earliest involvements in politics was volunteering for Democrat Doug Wilder in the 1991 Gubernatorial campaign, but in fact this just shows the depth of Perriello’s secret Libertarian identity. After all, the press has similarly described Doug Wilder as a libertarian:
“But Wilder’s campaign, careful not to appear too ardently pro-choice, kept the focus on Coleman’s position and cloaked the issue in libertarianism, Goldman said. A 30-second commercial, with Thomas Jefferson’s Monticello as a backdrop, framed the abortion issue as one of freedom and individual rights.”
“He said keeping bureaucrats out of the most personal of decisions was consistent with Virginia’s limited-government tradition. The point was driven home in a powerful television commercial by consultant Frank Greer that juxtaposed Wilder with iconic images: Thomas Jefferson; his home, Monticello, and the American flag.”
Now, the secret cabal between Doug Wilder and Tom Perriello to advance an agenda of freedom and individual rights may be a one of coincidence. But maybe there’s more here?
During his time in Congress, Perriello also voted against the reauthorization of the Patriot Act. One of only 87 Democrats to do so while the bulk of the caucus, 162 members, supported it. I know that the Patriot Act seems like a relic of another century (mid-20th century, circa 1984), but this was a very hot political issue in 2009.
Republicans like to talk about protecting individual rights and being skeptical of government power, but it was Democrats like Perriello who voted against the reauthorization, not Republicans. How libertarian of Perriello … but not nefarious.
Tom Perriello has stood with protests against Trump’s
Muslim ban travel ban. In talking about keeping Virginia as a firewall against President Trump’s hatred and bigotry, Perriello has highlighted the important role of our judiciary in defending our fundamental rights and liberties. This is clearly a libertarian streak, one that he’s shown in Congress as well with his vote against the Patriot Act.
Now any reasonable person would see the 2009 quote as a reference to these sensibilities, the political views of someone worried about government overreach trampling the rights of minorities. With the firing of FBI Director Comey this distrust of secretive, authoritarian power is needed now more than every. A deep appreciation for our judiciary and our constitutional checks and balances is a valuable trait to find in public servants. That’s also why Perriello has been an outspoken advocate of criminal justice reform in this campaign.
Or you could take the view of Ralph Northam, that in fact this is a sign that Tom Perriello is secretly a member of the Libertarian Party, a fringe political movement that rejected him in 2010 and has been highly critical of key Democratic priorities that Perriello has supported, such as the stimulus, cap and trade, and the Affordable Care Act.
What’s interesting about Northam’s tactics is that he’s trying to pin the claim of Democratic disloyalty on Perriello by bringing up a quote on his political sensibilities. Northam might want to check out his own record first before throwing stones.
Countering Jackson’s attempts to paint him as a big-government liberal, Northam brands himself as a fiscal conservative who is determined to sway moderates and independent voters.
“I don’t consider myself as a liberal. I consider myself as a moderate person. I think the less government, the better,” Northam said.
Northam has consistently embraced the fiscal conservative label, not just in 2013 but more recently at the start of this primary. Here are the facts on Ralph Northam’s world view. He believes that health care is a privilege, not a right, and ran away from defending the Affordable Care Act when times were tough (unlike Perriello).
Moderator: “Do you think that access to quality health care is a right or should it be left to the market or charity?”
Northam: “I believe it’s a privilege. And let me clarify that. If people can get up in the morning and go to work like I can, then it needs to be a privilege. They need to work for their health insurance, for their benefits. If they’re disabled, I will take the shirt off my back to help them.”
And while claiming to have always supported Dreamers, the truth is Northam has called illegal immigrants “a burden to our society.”
At the debate last night, Northam doubled down on his fiscally conservative record, telling Virginia voters that it’s not realistic to run on a platform of two years of debt-free college, community college, or apprenticeship. That it’s not realistic to advocate for tax reform to address Virginia’s income inequalities.
Make no mistake, Northam’s campaign is ignoring any real focus on the economy. Perriello is the only jobs candidate with an agenda focused on the economy for all Virginians, regardless of race or region. Northam tells us that as voters it’s wrong for us to want candidates who will invest in education and who will champion workers rights because Virginia is too fiscally conservative a state. Perhaps the problem is politicians like Northam are too fiscally conservative, not the voters?