The Devil in the Details


    Bob McDonnell had now unveiled the only budget he will propose in his term as governor, and I agree with Lowell’s assessment that it’s a “Scrooge budget,” worthy of Ebenezer Scrooge before he was redeemed by the ghosts of his past. present, and future.

    In his message, McDonnell made a big deal of the fact that he is not imposing a “mandate” on local government by deciding that they will have to pay half of the $2.2 billion he wants to add to the VRS trust fund. Well, as the overused adage says, “If it walks like a duck, talks like a duck, then it’s probably a duck.” Not only does he force that cost on localities, but he adds insult to injury by refusing to replace any of the $108 million in expiring federal stimulus money for public schools. And, to top off his lack of support for localities, he eliminates $109 million to cover inflation for non-classroom public school support services.

    As bad as his budget is for local government, however, to me the worst aspect is his plan to freeze hospital and nursing home rates for Medicaid recipients and to reduce indigent care at state medical school teaching hospitals. That means fewer beds will be ultimately be available for the elderly who have exhausted all their assets and need nursing home care, the largest single fraction of Medicaid spending and sure to grow as the population continues to age. Additionally, hospital rates for the insured and for private pay patients will rise to replace the cut to state teaching hospitals.

    McDonnell is cutting a total of $416 million from Virginia’s Department of Medical Assistance Services. As if all that wasn’t enough, he’s also reducing the income limits for eligibility for Medicaid long-term care, meaning fewer people will be able to qualify. All this on top of the fact that Virginia is already the stingiest state in its funding of Medicaid.

    McDonnell makes sure he gets in his ideological jabs, as well:

    The budget guts former Gov. Kaine’s signature achievement, pre-K education, a proven way to raise academic achievement for children. He again wants to end all subsidies to public radio and television, $7.2 million.

    As I read his budget message I couldn’t miss how he slammed President Obama’s Affordable Care Act, conveniently omitting to say that his rosy assumption of a 4.5% increase in state revenue growth in 2014 comes in large part from a proposed hike in federal payments to Virginia for increased Medicaid eligibility, that is if Republicans in Congress don’t succeed in cutting that program to the bone.

    Before state workers get all excited about the prospect of a 3% one-time bonus at the end of 2012, they might want to read the fine print. That bonus is contingent on there being unspent general fund money equal to twice the cost of the bonus.

    McDonnell’s solution for transportation is to rob Peter to pay Paul. He wants to shift money in the general fund from other services to road maintenance, increasing the share of the sales tax going to transportation from .5% to .55% and mandating that 75% of all future surplus money go to transportation.

    McDonnell has “balanced” his budget on the backs of children, local government, and the poor and elderly. He evidently did that in order to keep the yacht sales taxes at 2%, maintain state payments to welfare queens like the coal barons for not cutting jobs that they cut anyway, and to insure protection of a host of other tax breaks for the wealthy and the well-connected.

    This budget is the opposite of what He whose birthday many of us will be celebrating next week taught mankind. He told us we would be judged by how we treated the hungry, the poor, the homeless, not by how we protect the wealthy and the powerful.

    • Elaine in Roanoke

      Evidently, McDonnell doesn’t understand one salient fact about local governance: The main revenue producer for local government – and the main source of funding for education, police, fire fighters, etc. – is the local property tax, the tax hit hardest in the housing bubble crash. For many Virginia localities, the value of property for tax purposes has sharply declined in the past three years, many homes have been foreclosed on, and local revenue has been slammed. Now, McDonnell slams local government yet again.

    • Virginia Interfaith Center Responds to Governor McDonnell’s Budget

      Richmond, VA – Today the Virginia Interfaith Center responded to the Governor’s release of his biennial budget for FY2012 – 2014 by calling on the legislators of Virginia to pass a final budget which adopts a balanced approach that includes both targeted spending cuts and revenue increases in order to address the growing number of struggling Virginia families.

      The Governor’s budget proposal released this morning includes new funding for a number of worthwhile initiatives, but also cuts $779 million from public education and Medicaid rather than increasing revenues to balance the budget. The Commonwealth faces a budget deficit of approximately $1 billion over the next two years, and the Virginia Interfaith Center is advocating that sacrifice be shared amongst Virginians and new revenues be captured through the closure of tax loopholes rather than balancing the budget through cuts to programs that serve Virginia’s most vulnerable families.

      “Budgets are not just numbers; they are a reflection of a society’s priorities” said Rev. Shannon Sherwood Johnston, Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Virginia. “As more and more families struggle to find work and make ends meet, it is critical for their representatives to pass a budget that can address the increasing need for public services that keep those families afloat during tough times. I urge the Governor and the General Assembly to advance policies that give every Virginian a shot at a better life and make this Commonwealth a place where no one gets left behind.”

      One such policy is the state’s Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), which Governor McDonnell fully funded in the budget proposal released this morning. Now legislators must work to protect the families in need by ensuring programs such as the EITC, Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), and Family Access to Medical Insurance Security (FAMIS) are fully funded.

      “The economic realities our Commonwealth now faces are in many respects, quite dire,” said Holly Coy, Director of Programs for the Virginia Interfaith Center. “But make no mistake about it, our leaders can solve many of the daunting challenges they face, the only question is whether or not they are willing to put politics aside and work together for the best interest of the families they serve.”

      The Virginia Interfaith Center for Public Policy is Virginia’s oldest faith-based advocacy group and works to unite faith communities throughout the state to reduce poverty rates in Virginia by advocating for proven and effective public policies.