Video: As Virginia AG Mark Herring Introduces Package of Legislation to Combat Rise in Hate Crimes, State Sen. Dunnavant (R) Casts Doubt on Whether There’s Even BEEN a Rise in Hate Crimes
"I don't know if there's a rise or not...I don't have that objective information." - Sen. Siobhan Dunnavant (R)
The contrast between the following two items couldn’t be much greater.
First, check out the video of Virginia State Senator Siobhan Dunnavant (R-SD12, a district that went 56.5% for Tim Kaine in the Nov. 6 election) responding to a question from Rabbi Michael Knopf (of Temple Beth El in Richmond) last night at the “Encounter RVA” event at the Holocaust Museum in Richmond. Asked by Rabbi Knopf about her thoughts about the anti-Semitic murder spree in Pittsburgh, on the rise in anti-Semitism and “hate activity and hate groups of late,” “what’s causing that” and “what if anything can we do about,” Sen. Dunnavant (R) responded “I don’t know if there’s a rise or not…I don’t have that objective information.” The audience responded incredulously, and Rabbi Knopf cited the sources for his assertion about the rise in hate crimes. Dunnavant doubled down, said “I don’t know, I’d have to look into that to be honest,” which is to put it mildly a bizarre response given the reams of widely publicized evidence out there about the rise in white supremacy, hate crimes, etc. over the past couple years. Making matters even worse, Sen. Dunnavant then completely dodged the question of what, if anything, we can about the rise in hate cries, lamely saying she doesn’t have the “perfect solution for that” (note to Dunnavant: nobody’s asking for a PERFECT solution, just what IF ANYTHING can be done about this terrible situation!). Just remember this in 2019, as Dunnavant absolutely should NOT be reelected – and has just demonstrated why that’s the case.
In stark contrast, by the way, Del. Debra Rodman (D) totally nailed it, correctly stating that the rise in hate crimes and anti-Semitism “is coming from the hateful rhetoric that we’re hearing from our president.” Rodman also decried Trump’s and the GOP’s use of the “caravan as a wedge issue before the midterms.” According to Rodman, “for me was really horrifying…this has pushed people who are on the edge…and it goes along with the white nationalism that we’ve seen increase in the United States…This is a serious issue…Now it’s revved up…we’re seeing more hate crimes, the numbers are there….We’re in a really scary time in our nation…[The shooter in Pittsburgh] targeted this Jewish community not just because they were Jewish but that they were also supporting refugees.”
Next, check out the press release this morning by Virginia AG Mark Herring, unveiling “a package of legislation to protect Virginians from the rise in hate crimes and white supremacist violence occurring in Virginia and around the country.” As AG Herring points out, “Over the last 5 years, hate crimes in Virginia have risen by about 65 percent, and in 2017 alone, hate crimes increased by nearly 50 percent.” And again, somehow Virginia State Senator Siobhan Dunnavant (R) claims to not have seen any evidence that there’s been a rise in hate crimes, seemed to cast doubt on this fundamental fact of American life these days. Either Dunnavant is covering for her party/president, and/or she is just completely oblivious to what’s been going on in our country the past few years, and particularly since the candidacy and election of Donald Trump in 2016. Either way, she has no business being in the Virginia State Senate.
ATTORNEY GENERAL HERRING INTRODUCING LEGISLATION TO PROTECT VIRGINIANS FROM HATE CRIMES AND WHITE SUPREMACIST VIOLENCE
~ Package of bills comes in response to rise in white supremacist violence and hate crimes in Virginia and around the country; roundtable discussion series to be held across Virginia to discuss the issue and legislation ~
RICHMOND (November 15, 2018) – Attorney General Mark R. Herring today unveiled a package of legislation to protect Virginians from the rise in hate crimes and white supremacist violence occurring in Virginia and around the country. Attorney General Herring’s bills will update the Commonwealth’s hate crime and domestic terrorism laws, protect Virginians from violence and intimidation by hate groups and white supremacists, and make it harder for hate groups and white supremacists to threaten, intimidate, or hurt Virginians with firearms. Over the last 5 years, hate crimes in Virginia have risen by about 65 percent, and in 2017 alone, hate crimes increased by nearly 50 percent.
“In Virginia and across the country we are seeing hate turn deadly with frightening frequency. It is well past time to acknowledge the threat posed by hate and white supremacist violence and take action to stop it,” said Attorney General Herring. “We have to make it absolutely clear that white supremacist and extremist violence will not be tolerated in Virginia, and we need to do more than just say it. We have to pair our words with action. We must give our law enforcement agencies the tools they need to identify and prevent acts of violence and threats to our communities, and we must make it clear to vulnerable communities that they will be protected and cared for because they are important parts of our Virginia family.
“Over the past several sessions I have introduced legislation to address the rise in hate crimes and white supremacist violence, but nothing has been done and the threat continues to grow. That must end.
“I’m putting these ideas forward and convening these roundtables because it’s time for action. I will do everything I can and work with anyone who wants to ensure that all Virginians are protected from hate and violence, no matter what they look like, how they worship, where they come from, or who they love.”
A recently released report from the Virginia State Police shows that hate crimes in Virginia rose by nearly 50 percent from 2016 to 2017. Over the last 5 years, hate crimes in Virginia have risen by about 65 percent. Last year there were a total of 202 hate crimes in the state, including 38 racially-motivated assaults, 44 racially-motivated acts of vandalism/property destruction, and 32 acts of religious-motivated vandalism/property destruction.
This week the FBI came out with its annual Hate Crimes Statistics reportshowing that, not only were hate crimes on the rise, but so was the number of law enforcement agencies around the country that reported hate crimes having occurred. In 2017, law enforcement agencies reported 7,175 hate crimes to the FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting Program, an increase of about 17.5% over the previous year, constituting approximately 1,000 additional hate crimes. This included about 5,000 hate crimes against persons and about 3,000 property crimes.
Attorney General Herring and his team have been working with stakeholders from across the Commonwealth to develop legislation that will update hate crime laws and clearly define what constitutes a hate crime in Virginia, update domestic terrorism laws, and allow localities to decide whether firearms are permitted at events.
The bills are:
Updating Virginia’s definition of “hate crime”: This bill will create protections against hate crimes committed on the basis of gender, sexual orientation, gender identity, or disability.
Empowering the Attorney General to prosecute hate crimes: This bill will allow the Attorney General to prosecute hate crimes through the Commonwealth’s network of multijurisdictional grand juries.
Prohibiting Paramilitary Activity: This bill will further restrict the kind of paramilitary activity by white supremacist militias and similar groups that was seen in Charlottesville in August 2017.
Identifying and intervening in the actions of violent white supremacist and hate groups: This bill will give law enforcement agencies more tools to identify hate groups and white supremacist organizations that have perpetrated acts of violence, making it harder for these groups to operate and allowing for intervention before groups can commit planned acts of violence.
Firearms at Permitted Events: This bill authorizes communities to ban firearms in a public space during a permitted event, or an event that would otherwise require a permit.
Keeping guns away from those convicted of hate crimes. This bill will close a loophole and ensure that anyone convicted of a hate crime is barred from possessing a gun.
Attorney General Herring will convene a series of roundtable meetings across Virginia to discuss his legislation and the ways various communities are impacted by and responding to the rise in hate crimes and white supremacist violence. Virginia legislators are also invited to attend these discussions to hear about the experiences of people in their communities. Roundtables will be held:
Leesburg, November 27th
Alexandria, December 3rd
Richmond, December 4th
Charlottesville, December 5th
Norfolk, December 6th
Roanoke, December 19th
Attorney General Herring has been working for years to address the rise in hate crimes and white supremacist violence. Two years ago, he launchedwww.NoHateVA.com to give vulnerable communities more information and resources, and introduced legislation to update the definition of hate crime to include gender, gender identity, and sexual orientation, and asked the General Assembly for authority to prosecute hate crimes. Last year, he had two bills in the wake of the violence in Charlottesville to combat white supremacist gangs and militias that commit acts of violence and intimidation.
Sign up for the Blue Virginia weekly newsletter
