BREAKING: Speaker Howell Rules Massive Redraw of Districts Not Germane

    571
    8

    Regarding House Bill 259, the massive voting district redraw bill crossing over from the Virginia Senate, Del Mark Cole moved to accept the Senate amendment.

    Speaker Howell invoked the single object rule (no law shall embrace more than one object), but said it doesn’t apply. This amendment is to the same purpose.  So it doesn’t violate the single object rule.  Senate districts were added that were not in the title, but we have done that many times before, he said.

    But the germaneness issue is much more problematic. It means that the issue is in close relationship, appropriate, and relative.  It’s a parliamentary principle used since 1789 and in the Va House for centuries to produce orderly legislation. It prevents legislation not reasonably anticipated and for which legislators were not properly prepared, he said.

    House Bill 259 was introduced to make certain technical amendments, but not to completely re-do, the redistricting plan.  It strays dramatically.  This vast rewrite goes well beyond the usual precinct tweaks and the usual purpose of 259.  Some think germaneness is in the eyes of the beholder.  I think it is much more important for the integrity of the speaker’s chair.  And with that, Speaker Howell declared the vast, expansive redraw not germane.