Home 2019 Elections Barbara Comstock Says the Rich are Still Paying Too Much in Taxes

Barbara Comstock Says the Rich are Still Paying Too Much in Taxes


Cross posted from Dump Comstock

Barbara Comstock recently did an interview on the John Fredericks radio show where she fielded softball questions about Trump’s awesome new tax bill. Fredericks has apparently patched things up with Comstock after calling her a “creature of the swamp” on his show less than six months ago.

At the beginning of the segment, Fredericks announced that he is no longer supporting Comstock’s primary opponent Shak Hill, because Shak was not truthful with him during his last appearance on the show.

Fredericks better get ready to denounce Barbara Comstock (again), because she lied her face off during her interview.

The interview was a mixture of alternative facts and hypocritical nonsense. Let’s break it down.

Claim #1

There was a bipartisan consensus for years now that our business taxes were too high.

This is demonstrably false. Let’s start with the fact that zero Democrats in the House and zero Democrats in the Senate voted for this bill. That’s hardly a strong bipartisan consensus.

There’s also the fact that Hilary Clinton, who received three million more votes than Donald Trump, campaigned on a platform that promised to increase corporate income taxes.

Maybe Comstock was referring to Barack Obama who suggested modest corporate income tax cuts. The only problem with that theory is that he also proposed to completely offset this by closing corporate tax loopholes.

Sorry but we’re not seeing the bipartisan consensus here. Only one party is consistently agitating for corporations to pay less in taxes.

Claim #2

Well listen, you’ve not had Democrats promote tax cuts since President Kennedy in the sixties.

This is a straight up lie. In fact, EVERY Democratic President since Kennedy has called for tax cuts.

Lyndon Johnson

In 1964, President Johnson signed a bipartisan tax bill known as the Tax Reduction Act. Individual income tax rates were cut across the board by approximately 20%.

Jimmy Carter

In President Carter’s message to Congress in 1978 he proposed the following:

  • $17 billion in net income tax cuts for individuals, through across-the-board rate reductions and a new personal credit, focused primarily on low and middle-income taxpayers
  • $6 billion in net income tax cuts for small and large corporations, through reductions in the corporate tax rates and extensions of the investment tax credit
  • $2 billion for elimination of the excise tax on telephone calls and a reduction in the payroll tax for unemployment insurance

Bill Clinton

Bill Clinton campaigned on cutting taxes for people making less than $80,000 per year (and no change for people making up to $200,000)

Barack Obama

Presumably Comstock is able to remember way back to when Barack Obama was President and cut taxes on two separate occasions. There was the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 which cut taxes by $237 billion.

Then there was the American Taxpayer Relief Act of 2012 which passed with strong bipartisan support in the Senate but was opposed by a majority of Republicans in the House.

Claim #3

I also don’t think anyone should have to pay more than a third of their income to the federal government so I’d like to see the top rates … all the rates … a little lower

This statement pretty much speaks for itself. Trump just slashed taxes for the top 1% but that’s not good enough for Rep Comstock – she thinks they should pay even less. Trump cut the top marginal rate from 39.6% to 37% but Comstock thinks it should be cut all the way to 33%.

Claim #4

It’s just bizarre. We should be happy for anybody seeing their wages increased

Back in 2012, Comstock told Neil Cavuto that people should be happy about the great benefits one gets with a minimum wage job. If you want higher wages just get a better job!

“So instead what we need to have is people to understand that these are entry level jobs, you move your way up, you can get good benefits in these jobs, get good training, this is great for people.”

In the Virginia Legislature, Comstock was on the Commerce and Labor Committee that killed two minimum wage increase bills. House Bill 536 would have increased the minimum wage $1 from $7.25 to $8.25 an hour, and House Bill 32 would have made a $1.25 increase to $8.50 an hour. Both bills were tabled by voice vote.

In 2015 she voted against an increase in the federal minimum wage.

None of this matters

In the end, none of this matters because even John Fredericks knows that Barbara Comstock is toast in November.


Sign up for the Blue Virginia weekly newsletter

Previous articleFollowing “Summer of Hate” 2017, Charlottesville Mayor Mike Signer Bows Out After One Term
Next articleIn-State Tuition At Risk for Virginia DREAMers; Study Finds Extending College Access a Low-Cost, High-Reward Investment