Home Climate change The Other Shoe Drops: APCo Follows Dominion in Seeking Rate Increase Due...

The Other Shoe Drops: APCo Follows Dominion in Seeking Rate Increase Due to High Fossil Fuel Costs


by Ivy Main, cross posted from Power for the People VA

Virginia residents who buy electricity from Appalachian Power will see a rate increase of almost 16% this year if the State Corporation Commission approves the utility’s request to recover more than $361 million it has spent on higher-than-expected coal and natural gas prices. APCo proposes to recover the excess over two years, meaning rates will remain elevated even if fossil fuel prices drop. According to the filing, a customer who uses 1,000 kWh per month would see an increase of $20.17.

The SCC is likely to approve the request because it has little room to do otherwise. Virginia law allows utilities to recover their spending on fuel dollar-for-dollar, though they cannot tack on a profit for themselves. Last month, the SCC approved Dominion’s request to increase rates by an average of nearly $15 per month for the next three years to cover past excess fuel costs.

The good news, says APCo, is that Virginia customers will see lower bills in the future because the utility is investing in renewable energy. “Incorporating more renewable sources of power into the company’s energy mix is another step in reducing customer fuel costs,” declares the company’s press release, issued the same day as its SCC filing. “As Appalachian Power adds more renewables, there is less need for coal and natural gas to generate power.”

Well, yes, but wouldn’t it have been nice if APCo had come to this conclusion before now? The current situation was entirely predictable. A supply glut kept natural gas prices low for almost a decade, but drilling companies weren’t making money. Today’s higher prices make it profitable to drill for gas, but oil and gas companies don’t trust that the market will stay strong, so they are returning profits to shareholders rather than investing in new wells. So tight supplies may keep prices high. Or not! Nobody knows. (As for coal, natural gas generation and coal are ready substitutes for each other, so coal prices track natural gas prices.)

For years clean energy advocates like me have been urging utilities and the SCC to value price stability in generation planning, only to be ignored. Other states took the lead in installing price-stable renewable energy, while Virginia added more gas plants. When I dug into the data this summer, it became clear that the great majority of states with lower rates than Virginia also had higher amounts of renewable energy in their generation mix. I’ve reprinted a summary table here.

State Price cents/kWh % RE source of RE
Virginia 12.83 7 biomass, hydro, solar
Idaho 9.86 74 mostly hydro
Washington 10.12 75 mostly hydro
North Dakota 10.48 40 mostly wind
Utah 10.66 15 mostly solar
Montana 11.00 52 mostly hydro
Wyoming 11.06 19 mostly wind
Nebraska 11.11 28 mostly wind
Oregon 11.22 68 mostly hydro, some wind
Missouri 11.54 12 mostly wind
Arkansas 11.75 10 mostly hydro
Louisiana 11.98 4 biomass
South Dakota 12.03 82 wind, hydro
Iowa 12.09 60 almost all wind
North Carolina 12.26 16 mostly solar and hydro
Oklahoma 12.38 45 mostly wind
Kentucky 12.63 7 hydro

I compiled this table in July, using then-current Energy Information Agency data. Now EIA has updated its data, and Virginia’s position is worse than ever. As of July 2022, Virginia’s average residential electricity rate has now hit 14.42 cents/kWh. This puts us above every state in the South Atlantic except Georgia. (Poor Georgia comes in at 16.02, but that’s what building nuclear plants will do for your rates.) Meanwhile, the states whose rates increased the least are those with high levels of wind, solar and hydro.

This isn’t rocket science, folks. Wind and solar have lower levelized costs than coal and gas, and they insulate consumers from the volatility of the world oil and gas markets. You don’t have to be a climate advocate to understand this, but apparently it helps.


Sign up for the Blue Virginia weekly newsletter

Previous articleSunday News: “Here’s What China Experts Are Saying About Xi’s Big Speech”; “Iran’s Evin Prison Set on Fire as Protests Spread”; “Shooting at Russian Military Training Ground”; “Obama’s Advice For Democrats.”; “Trump Tried to Destroy the Constitution”
Next articleWith Just Over Three Weeks Until the Crucial 2022 Midterm Elections and the Fate of Our Democracy on the Line, “We decide. You will decide.”