A Sad September


    This morning, my Jewish husband reminded me that tomorrow is Erev Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year and the start of the High Holy Days. Even though I am a Christian, I always go with him to Rosh Hashanah  and Kol Nidre services on the eve of the Day of Repentence, Yom Kipper. His reminder came right after I had listened to the news that Gen. David Petraus, commander of American forces in Afghanistan, had  remarked on the dangers of the proposed action by the so-called “Dove World Christian Center” in Florida to burn Korans, the holy book of Muslims, on September 11.

    “It could endanger troops and it could endanger the overall effort in Afghanistan,” Gen. Petraeus said.

    Petraus’ deputy, Lt. Gen. William Caldwell, spoke on CNN, saying, “We very much feel that this [action] can jeopardize the safety of our men and women that are serving over here in the country,”  Caldwell is the head of NATO efforts to train Afghan security forces.

    I suddenly had a flashback to what I had read about Nazi Germany, where desecration of the Torah, holy book of the Jews, was encouraged and practiced with great energy. Also, to Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury, which I taught for many years to my students, a novel about a time and place where books have become subversive and must be kept from the sheep-like populace.

    It was Heinrich Heine who said, “Where one burns books, one will, in the end, burn people.” Is that what my country has come to, in the name of free speech by a hate-filled, bigoted “church”?  

    This weekend in September is sacred to many people. It is the start of High Holy Days for Jews. It also is the end of Ramadan, a month of fasting for Muslims, ushering in Eid, a festival that this year American Muslims are afraid to celebrate too openly for fear of some bigoted backlash. In addition, it is a sad commemoration  of the deaths of almost 3,000 innocents who were sacrificed to the hatred of Osama bin Laden and al Qaida operatives.

    The last thing that my country should stand for is the same standard that Nazi Germany had for books that they disagreed with, the same sort of hatred and bigotry that drives bin Ladin to sacrifice innocents to his evil crusade.

    If one group of Americans think they have the right to offend another group by burning their sacred books, by the same token the offended people should have the right to demand respect for their beliefs in this nation. Otherwise, a Nazi resurgence is upon us, in the guise of bigots who preach in the name of the Prince of Peace, aided and abetted by egotistical zealots who have their viewpoint aired on television news far too much.

    I believe that the ironically named Dove World Christian Center is flirting with treason…and getting away with it.  

    • richmonder

      I assume this so-called minister wouldn’t be pulling this stunt if he didn’t expect to get lots of publicity for it. It may not be much of a damage control tactic, but if the networks can deny them the air time, it might deter this being widely imitated by other fringe groups.  

    • blue bronc

      The VFW is standing up against the burning of religious books.

      VFW Strongly Against ‘Burn A Koran Day’

      “The First Amendment may protect the pastor and his follower’s right to protest, but there is nothing to be gained and everything to lose from this selfish act,” said Eubank. “Our war is against a small number of religious extremists who kill indiscriminately and without remorse. Let’s not allow an equally small number of religious extremists in America to widen the war.”


    • Burgesses1619

      What luck for rulers that men do not think. – Adolf Hitler

      while two other individuals taught

      The price good men pay for indifference to public affairs is to be ruled by evil men. – Plato


      The way to combat noxious ideas is with other ideas. The way to combat falsehoods is with truth. – William O. Douglas, US jurist (1898 – 1980)

      We can’t be complacent. We need to better learn to fight ignorance and hate.

    • kindler

      I found this out because my 81-year-old Dad, who has a heart condition, was very upset to hear that his temple in Chicago is going to be picketed by the same freak show that protests at military funerals — during High Holiday services.  

      It’s awful that intolerance is on the rise in the U.S., while the Republicans, Fox News, Tea Party and company go wink, wink, don’t see a thing.  But we don’t have to stand for it — it’s up to us to stand up for America’s values, and shout these devils down.