Home VA GOP Despite Losing 15 Seats in November 2017, Republicans Decimated Virginia Democrats’ Legislation

Despite Losing 15 Seats in November 2017, Republicans Decimated Virginia Democrats’ Legislation


People can try to put a positive spin on the 2018 Virginia General Assembly session all they want – and many have, for a variety of political reasons – but the facts don’t lie. Check out the following graphics, courtesy of VPAP, and decide for yourself whether I was right or not when I called the GOP-controlled 2018 Virginia General Assembly a nearly total #FAIL.

First, check out the glaring disparity in outcomes of bills sponsored by Republicans and by Democrats. In the State Senate, Republicans saw 46% of their bills passed and 28% killed (a plus-18-point success margin), with 9% “consolidated” into other bills and 17% “carried over to 2019” (alive to fight another year). In stark contrast, Senate Democrats had a 27%-46% (minus-19-points) pass/fail rate, with 13% “consolidated” and 14% “carried over to 2019.” Blech!!!

But wait, it gets worse – much, much worse – when we turn to the Virginia House of Delegates. Yes, that’s the chamber where Democrats picked up a whopping 15 seats this past November, climbing within 1 seat of a 50-50 tie. Yes despite this – or perhaps because of it? – Republicans stacked the committees (so much for proportional representation or GOP respect for democracy!) and absolutely decimated Democratic legislation. Thus, while 44% of GOP-sponsored bills passed the House, only 18% (!) of Democratic-sponsored bills passed vs. 81% that were killed by Republicans. That’s right, let me repeat this: despite gaining 15 seats in the Virginia House of Delegates in November, Democrats’ bills were mowed down by Republicans at a rate of 81% failed, 18% passed. Incredible. And by the way, of those 18% that passed, from what I’ve seen, most were non-controversial, relatively minor bills, with VERY few exceptions. In contrast, basically every piece of consequential or major legislation introduced by Democrats was killed by Republicans in the Virginia House of Delegates. Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr.

But wait, you ask, haven’t things gotten better compared to previous years? Uhhh…looks like the answer to that question is a flat “nope.” For instance, the percentage of bills that passed in 2018 was just 33%, lower than in 2017 (40%), 2016 (39%) or 2015 (38%). One slight glimmer of hope, at least, is that the percentage of bills killed without any recorded vote plummeted, from 73% in 2016 and 54% in 2017 to just 28% this year (note: that percentage SHOULD be zero).
As for WHERE Democrats’ bills were killed, that was obvious if you were following the 2018 Virginia General Assembly. Still, it’s very helpful to see the actual numbers laid out in graphic (in two senses of that word) format. Not surprisingly, Republicans chose to kill Democrats’ bills at the “lowest” level possible – House Subcommittees, the slaughterhouse where 874 bills went to die. Combine that with House Committee, where 294 more bills were killed, and the 51-49 GOP majority House of Delegates was a disaster for Democrats, despite (or because of?) our gains last November. In contrast, “only” 300 bills died in Senate Committee and 62 on the GOP-controlled Senate floor or in GOP-controlled Conference Committee. Still very bad, but not as horrendous as the House of Delegates.

Also note that, in spite of reforms to reduce the number of bills deep-sixed without even a recorded vote, 429 bills died that way in 2018. Pathetic.

Bottom line: this shit isn’t going to change for the better until Democrats control both the House of Delegates and the State Senate. Get ready for 2019…we’ve got a LOT of work cut out for us still!

  • Nadja Zalokar Golding

    All good points except the headline. It should have been “Despite Losing 15 seats in the November 2017 Election, Republicans Decimated Virginia Democrats’ Legislation”

    • Yeah, good point – fixed it. Thanks.

  • linda1pebv

    This is why the 94th and the 28th were such critical outcomes. Now we have no other choice but to decimate the GOP in 2019. That means holding the 15 and taking a bunch more for good measure. These were recorded votes in committees. We KNOW who killed every bill from anti-Gerrymandering to gun safety. We know the names. Take them out.

    • True Virginian

      I can only hope with Virginia holding its legislative elections in off years conservative funding and turnout in 19 will stay the angry blue wave we had in 17.

  • RobertColgan

    It is amazing how a SUPERMAJORITY of 1, or 2 delegates can so clearly evidence AN OVERWHELMING MANDATE !!!

    What comic book are these characters out of…?
    I have —-as result of the actions of the R people in the VA Assembly and the R circus act devoid of any sense in DC—–lost what little respect for Republicans I may have had.

    We need gender equality. It is not enough simply to elect Ds to replace faulty Rs……the whole system is faultworthy as long as men lord it over women by maintaining the patriarchal dominance in numbers.
    We need term limits……
    We need an end to campaign money that purchases votes (but is claimed not to influence decisions)
    These things are simple to install, and could vastly reform politicking in States and Federal governments…..but as long as the politicos themselves make the rules—-they will make rules favorable to maintaining the status quo:
    “Power madness” should be in the DSM5.

  • Goengo

    Maybe – just maybe, it’s because the new delegates are inexperienced.

    • True Virginian

      and unqualified except for their intersectionalism.

  • True Blue

    The angry red waves of 2010 and 2011 elected many inexperienced and unqualified delegates, and so-called GOP leadership made sure to rig elections in the future with gerrymandering. A blue wave of 2017 flipped fifteen house seats, but the few remaining went into overtime yet did not prevail. Thus, the desperate and so-called GOP leadership found new ways to rig legislation in 2018 by stacking committees. Charts say it all.

  • Anthony Shifflett

    What did everyone expect? When we didn’t get a majority you can only expect this. Just have to keep pounding away. Need to do a better job with strategy for when we get to Richmond with pumped up numbers.