Home Virginia Politics Chaz Nuttycombe’s First Cut at 2020 Census “Fair Maps”: 60 Northam-40 Gillespie...

Chaz Nuttycombe’s First Cut at 2020 Census “Fair Maps”: 60 Northam-40 Gillespie for the House of Delegates; 24 Northam-16 Gillespie for the State Senate

Currently, it's 55D-45R in the House of Delegates, 21D-19R in the State Senate...


With 2020 Census numbers finally available, states now can really get going on drawing new Congressional and state legislative maps. That includes here in Virginia, where we’ve got a bipartisan redistricting commission – comprised of politicians and citizens (selected by the politicians, basically) – that will be very busy the next few months. For an idea of what “fair” maps might look like, see below for what Chaz Nuttycombe has put together as a first cut for the State Senate and House of Delegates. These will be very helpful to keep handy as the redistricting commission gets to work, so we can compare what they come up with to the maps developed by independent, non-partisan, outside experts…

  • First, Chaz’s first draft of a “fair” House of Delegates map has 60 districts won by Democrat Ralph Northam in the 2017 gubernatorial election vs. 40 won by Republican Ed Gillespie. That compares to a 55D-45R House of Delegates split right now, so it seems that after redistricting – assuming it is “fair” – Democrats have upside potential of maybe 5 seats or so. That corresponds to what I’d been told recently by a senior Virginia Democratic elected official, that Dems could pick up 5 House of Delegates seats after redistricting due to population shifts alone: 2 in Northern Virginia, 2 in Hampton Roads, 1 in the Richmond area.  As for Republicans, my source told me that Republicans could lose 2 seats in SW Virginia, 2 in Southside Virginia and 1 in the Shenandoah region.
  • Chaz also notes that this “fair” map is 67 Kaine-33 Stewart. Of course, since that was a federal election (for U.S. Senate), it’s not really comparable to a state legislative election, particularly in a non-gubernatorial year, so I wouldn’t use that for comparison, particularly.

  • As for the State Senate, Chaz has it at 24 Northam – 16 Gillespie, which compares to the current 21D-19R State Senate partisan makeup. And again, population shifts are likely going to result in less representation relatively speaking for SW Virginia and Southside, versus MORE representation for rapidly growing areas like Northern Virginia.

  • Also, check out Dave’s Redistricting Map for some possible Congressional, State Senate and House of Delegates maps – “Most Proportional,” “Most Competitive,” “Best Minority Representation,” “Most Compact,” “Least Splitting.”

  • And check out these Congressional district maps by Christian Heiens, a Republican and the 2018 VPAP pundit.

UPDATE Monday morning: Here’s a “fair map” by Chaz Nuttycombe for Virginia Congressional districts, which has it at 7 Northam-4 Gillespie and 9 Kaine-2 Stewart. Obviously VA06 and VA09 stay deep-red, with VA01 and VA05 lighter red, while VA03, VA08 and VA11 are dark blue, VA10 and VA04 blue, VA02 and VA07 light blue.


Sign up for the Blue Virginia weekly newsletter

Previous articleStrike Back Against the (Republican) Machine…By Supporting Del. Rodney Willett (D-HD73)’s Reelection Campaign!
Next articleMonday News: “The Tragedy of Afghanistan”; “Chaos at Kabul airport as thousands of Afghans try to flee Taliban”; “US could see 200,000 Covid cases a day again: ‘Unvaccinated are sitting ducks’”; “It Was a Terrifying Census for White Nationalists”